Report A Claim Foremost BW Auto 1-800-274-7865 Claim site click here Foremost Star 1-800-527-3907 Claim site click here Grange Insurance 1-800-445-3030 Claim site click here Liberty Mutual 1-844-825-2467 Claim site click here National General (Encompass Insurance) 1-800-325-1088 Claim site click here Progressive 1-800-776-4737 (option 1) Claim site click here Safeco 1-877-941-5450 Claim site click here Travelers 1-800-252-4633 Claim site click here